Survivor Wiki

Walking on Thin Ice

2,975pages on
this wiki
Add New Page
Add New Page Talk0

"Walking on Thin Ice"
Gross food samoaErik takes on Natalie in the Reward Challenge.
Episode Information
Season: Samoa
Episode Number: 5/15 (261)
Original Release: October 15, 2009
Viewership (in millions): 11.78[1]
Ratings/Share (18-49): 3.5/10 Summary: Link
Episode Chronology
Previous: "Hungry for a Win"
Next: "This Is the Man Test"

Walking on Thin Ice is the fifth episode of Survivor: Samoa.


Day 12

Day 13

Day 14



Challenge: Samoa Smoothies
Jeff will spin the roulette-style wheel while one member of each tribe rolls a ball. The ball will land on different ingredients. Jeff will then blend those ingredients to make a Samoa Smoothie. Each time a player gulps the entire drink down, they score one point for their tribe. The first tribe to accumulate five points wins the challenge.
Reward: An assortment of meats and spices
Winner: Galu (sent Shambo Waters to observe Foa Foa)

Reward Challenge: Samoa Smoothies
Result Tribe Competitors Sit-Outs
Won Galu S19 brett tS19 dave tS19 erik tS19 monica tS19 russells tS19 shambo t
Brett, Dave, Erik, Monica, Russell S., & Shambo
S19 john tS19 kelly tS19 laura t
John, Kelly, & Laura
Lost Foa Foa S19 ashley tS19 jaison tS19 liz tS19 mick tS19 natalie tS19 russellh t
Ashley, Jaison, Liz, Mick, Natalie, & Russell H.
Round Breakdown
Round Food Foa Foa Score Galu Score Total Score
Round 1 Giant Clam,
Octopus &
Sea Snail
S19 jaison t 1 S19 shambo t 1 1-1
Round 2 Jellyfish &
S19 russellh t 1 S19 russells t 1 2-2
Round 3 Giant Clam,
Sea Cucumber &
S19 mick t 1 S19 brett t 1 3-3
Round 4 Sea Urchin &
Sea Weed
S19 liz t 1 S19 monica t 1 4-4
Round 5 Sea Slug Guts &
S19 ashley t 0 S19 dave t 1 5-4


Challenge: Sack Attack
One man and one woman from each tribe will both hold on to a rope connected to a net while members of the opposing tribe will attempt to shoot coconuts into that net. The more coconuts in the net, the heavier the net will become until the tribe members can no longer hold on. The tribe that holds on to their net the longest wins immunity.
Winner: Galu

Immunity Challenge: Sack Attack
Result Tribe Net Holders Shooters Sit-Outs
Won Galu S19 laura tS19 russells t
Laura & Russell S.
S19 erik tS19 john tS19 kelly tS19 monica t
Erik, John, Kelly, & Monica
S19 brett tS19 dave tS19 shambo t
Brett, Dave, & Shambo
Lost Foa Foa S19 liz tS19 russellh t
Liz & Russell H.
S19 ashley tS19 jaison tS19 mick tS19 natalie t
Ashley, Jaison, Mick, & Natalie

Tribal Council

Tribal Council 5:
Foa Foa
S19 ashley t
Ashley (5 votes)
S19 jaison tS19 liz t
S19 mick tS19 natalie tS19 russellh t
Jaison, Liz, Mick, Natalie, & Russell H.
S19 liz t
Liz (1 vote)
S19 ashley t
S19 ashley bw
Ashley Trainer

Voting Confessionals

Jaison did not say anything when he voted.

(voting against Ashley) Listen, please don't take this too personally. You know, we're basically down to six people; we had to choose somebody. I think this is the consensus. Um, I think, just around camp, if you had a little more motivation, sort of self-motivated, and I think the agreement is, maybe at this point, you might be one of the weaker links physically, um, so that's what this is based on, and nothing else. This is tough. I'm sorry to see you go. We'll talk soon.


(voting against Ashley) Ashley, I'm voting for you because, uh, this what my core alliance went with, but, um, this is the hardest vote, I think, I'll make in the entire game. I'm sorry. Love you, girl. You were awesome.


(voting against Ashley) Sorry, but everyone wants to put you out of your misery.


(voting against Ashley) You're lazy. You can't think for yourself. You can't do for yourself, and that's why you gotta go home. It's because of me that you're going home. I'm out here playing for one million dollars; never trust me.

Russell H.

(voting against Liz) I trust you the least out of everyone.


Final Words

Survivor was the hardest thing I've ever done in my entire life, but it was the best experience. I have learned so much about myself. I'm such a high maintenance girl, at home. I never thought in a million years that I would be able to go through the things that I've gone through here. I wish that my tribe would beat Galu, and take some wins. Hopefully, one of them can win the million dollars.

Ashley Trainer

Still in the Running

S19 marisa bw
S19 mike bw
S19 betsy bw
S19 ben bw
S19 yasmin bw
S19 ashley bw
S19 brett t
S19 dave t
S19 erik t
Foa Foa
S19 jaison t
S19 john t
S19 kelly t
S19 laura t
Foa Foa
S19 liz t
Foa Foa
S19 mick t
S19 monica t
Foa Foa
S19 natalie t
 Russell H.
Foa Foa
S19 russellh t
S19 russells t
S19 shambo t



Other Wikis

Random Wiki