Yeah, I know that this has been done heaps of times. But I had an idea for another all-star season, where the tribes are made by how the person was eliminated. There are only one and two time players. Here it is!


Soliantu is made up of contestants that didn't have luck on their side. 

Enil Edam is made up of contestants that were eliminated directly by a hidden immunity idol.

Ulong is made up of contestants that had the potential to go far, but didn't, becuase their tribe were Ulonged.

Pagong is made up of contestants that were the victims of a pagonging.

Contestant Original Tribe Absorbed Tribe Merged Tribe Finish Votes
S25 pete bw Pete Yurkowski
26, Holmdel, NJ
Enil Edam 1st Voted Out
Day 2
S19 ashley bw Ashley Trainer
27, Maple Grove, MN
Ulong 2nd Voted Out
Day 4
S10 james bw James Miller
42, Mobile, AL
Ulong 3rd Voted Out
Day 6
S23 whitney bw Whitney Duncan
29, Nashville, TN
Pagong 4th Voted Out
Day 8
S2 elisabeth bw Elisabeth Hasselbeck
36, Cranston, RI
Pagong Soliantu 5th Voted Out
Day 11
S25 rc bw RC Saint-Amour
28, New York, NY
Enil Edam Enil Edam 6th Voted Out
Day 13
S20 james bw James Clement
37, Lafayette, LA
Soliantu Soliantu 7th Voted Out
Day 15
S4 paschal bw Paschal English
69, Thomaston, GA
Soliantu Soliantu 8th Voted Out
Day 17
S3 silas bw Silas Gaither
36, Germantown, TN
Soliantu Soliantu 9th Voted Out
Day 19
S16 alexis bw Alexis Jones
30, Los Angeles, CA
Enil Edam Enil Edam Libertad 10th Voted Out
1st Jury Member
Day 22
S14 rocky bw Rocky Reid
35, San Diego, CA
Ulong Enil Edam 11th Voted Out
2nd Jury Member
Day 24
S13 adam bw Adam Gentry
35, San Diego, CA
Pagong Enil Edam 12th Voted Out
3rd Jury Member
Day 26
S20 jt bw JT Thomas
29, Samson, AL
Enil Edam Enil Edam 13th Voted Out
4th Jury Member
Day 28
S21 yve bw Yve Rojas
45, Kansas City, MO
Ulong Enil Edam 14th Voted Out
5th Jury Member
Day 30
S27 katie bw Katie Collins
26, New York City, NY
Soliantu Soliantu 15th Voted Out
6th Jury Member
Day 32
S1 colleen bw Colleen Haskell
37, Miami Beach, FL
Pagong Soliantu 16th Voted Out
7th Jury Member
Day 34
S4 hunter bw Hunter Ellis
45, La Jolla, CA
Ulong Soliantu 17th Voted Out
8th Jury Member
Day 36
S14 stacy bw Stacy Kimball
34, Boulder, CO
Enil Edam Enil Edam 18th Voted Out
9th Jury Member
Day 38
S19 brett bw Brett Clouser
28, Los Angeles, CA
Pagong Enil Edam Runner-Up 6
S7 darrah t Darrah Johnson
32, Liberty, MS
Soliantu Soliantu Sole Survivor 2