• SimBrotherCo


    February 9, 2014 by SimBrotherCo

    Castaway Original Tribe Finish Redemption Island
    Status Votes
    Tony Vlachos
    39, Jersey City, NJ
    2nd Voted Out
    Day 5 1st Eliminated
    Day 6 5
    Spencer Bledsoe
    21, Chicago, IL
    1st Voted Out
    Day 3 2nd Eliminated
    Day 9 5
    Sarah Lacina
    29, Cedar Rapids, IA
    3rd Voted Out
    Day 8 3rd Eliminated
    Day 12 6
    Jeremiah Wood
    34, Dobson, NC
    5th Voted Out
    Day 14 4th Eliminated
    Day 15 5
    J'Tia Taylor
    31, Chicago, IL
    6th Eliminated
    Day 17 5th Eliminated
    Day 18 5
    Brice Johnston
    27, Philadelphia, PA
    7th Voted Out
    Day 19 6th Eliminated
    Day 20 5
    rowspan="2" David Samson
    45, Plantation, FL rowspan="2" 4th Voted Out
    Day 11 1st Returnee
    Day 20 13
    9th Voted Out
    Day 23 7th Eliminated
    1st Jury Member
    Day 25
    Jefra Bland
    22, Campbellsville, KY
    10th Voted Out
    Day 24 8th Eliminated
    2nd Jury Member
    Day 25 12
    LJ McKanas…

    Read more >
  • SimBrotherCo

    My friend Ian & I came up with an All-Star cast for the brains vs. beauty vs. brawn twist. This is our cast, the results of our season will be posted here!

    While a lot of the people could fit into multiple categories we wanted to have people who could be well rounded as well, as that's the whole point of the twist for Survivor: Cagayan!

    Only 1 & 2 time players were eligible to return.

    (Aparri=Brawn, Luzon=Brain, Solana=Beauty)

    Contestant Original Tribe Swapped Tribe Merged Tribe Finish Votes
    Edna Ma
    38, Los Angeles, CA

    1st Voted Out
    Day 3 4
    Marcus Lehman
    34, Atlanta, GA

    2nd Voted Out
    Day 6 4
    Troyzan Robertson
    52, Miami, FL

    3rd Voted Out
    Day 8 5
    width="10%" Crystal Cox
    34, Durham, NC

    4th Voted Out
    Day 11 3
    Mikayla Wingle
    24, Tampa, FL

    5th Voted Out …

    Read more >
  • SimBrotherCo

    Does anyone find it frustrating that we've had people like Malcolm and Andrea playing as hard as they can to get further in the game, and they come up short when there's someone left in the game *cough* EDDIE *cough* who doesn't care about the game at all, who's done nothing to try and keep him in the game, who jumped off an endurance challenge a minute into it for doughnuts when he could've been voted out. I don't care if someone's not the best strategist in the game, but he's not even trying!

    I love blindsides like the one we had tonight. I love Andrea, but that was a great blindside, but what isn't great is when there are so few people left that are even making a solid attempt to play the game, we have Cochran, Dawn, and Brenda...but rea…

    Read more >
  • SimBrotherCo

    I feel like there's been a lot of debate within the Survivor community over whether Malcolm is considered a Hero or a Villain and I wanted the wiki's opinion on this.

    I said at the end of Philippines I thought Malcolm was "The perfect villain, who ended up in the ultimate hero situation."

    That being said, I personally think he's more of a villain than a hero.

    Not in the sense that he's a jerk, but he's a very crafty player, but also has a great sense of humor.

    What are your thoughts?

    Read more >
  • SimBrotherCo

    I really want the Wiki's opinion on this.

    I think since Cook Islands, anyone who has made the merge has been given a spot on the jury until now.

    The jury traditionally starts at 12 anyways, and considering that Corinne made the merge, the jury, and is clearly one of the best jurors of all time, I want to know if you guys think it's fair that she's not on the jury!

    Read more >