This is how I want to see it happen.
| Contestant | Tribe Affiliation | Finish | Votes Against | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original Tribe | Switched Tribe | Merged Tribe | ||||
| Nadiya Anderson 28, Edgewater, NJ Natalie's Twin Sister | Coyopa | 1st Voted Out Day 3 | |||
| Val Collins 35, Foxboro, MA Jeremy's wife | Coyopa | 2nd Voted Out Day 6 | |||
| John Rocker 39, Atlanta, GA Julie's boyfriend | Coyopa | 3rd Voted Out Day 8 | |||
| Reed Kelly 31, New York City, NY Josh's boyfriend | Hunahpu | Quit Day 11 | |||
| Dale Wentworth 55, Ephrata, WA Kelley's father | Coyopa | Coyopa | 4th Voted Out Day 14 | ||
| Jeremy Collins 36, Foxboro, MA Val's husband | Hunahpu | Coyopa | 5th Voted Out Day 17 | ||
| Drew Christy 25, Winter Park, FL Alec's brother | Hunahpu | Coyopa | Tikiano | 6th Voted Out Day 20 | |
| Wes Nale 23, Shreveport, LA Keith's son | Coyopa | Hunahpu | 7th Voted Out 1st Jury Member Day 22 | ||
| Missy Payne 47, Dallas, TX Baylor's mother | Hunahpu | Hunahpu | 8th Voted out 2nd Jury Member Day 25 | ||
| Josh Canfield 32, New York City, NY Reed's boyfriend | Coyopa | Hunahpu | 9th Voted Out 3rd Jury Member Day 27 | ||
| Alec Christy 22, Winter Park, FL Drew's brother | Coyopa | Coyopa | 10th Voted Out 4th Jury Member Day 30 | ||
| Julie McGee 34, Atlanta, GA John's girlfriend | Hunahpu | Coyopa | 11th Voted Out 5th Jury Member Day 33 | ||
| Baylor Wilson 20, Nashville, TN Missy's daughter | Coyopa | Coyopa | 12th Voted Out 6th Jury Member Day 36 | ||
| Jon Misch 26, Waterford, MI Jaclyn's boyfriend | Hunahpu | Coyopa | 13th Voted Out 7th Jury Member Day 37 | ||
| Jaclyn Schultz 25, Las Vegas, NV Jon's girlfriend | Coyopa | Hunahpu | 14th Voted Out 8th Jury Member Day 38 | ||
| Keith Nale 53, Shreveport, LA Wes's father | Hunahpu | Hunahpu | Second Runner-Up | ||
| Natalie Anderson 28, Edgewater, NJ Nadiya's twin sister | Hunahpu | Hunahpu | Runner-Up | ||
| Kelley Wentworth 28, Seattle, WA Dale's daughter | Hunahpu | Hunahpu | Sole Survivor | ||
