I have a problem with the idea of what constitutes a win at Redemption Island. Matt Elrod's article claims he won 10 of his 11 Redemption Island duels, but in reality, he lost at least 3. Mike kicked his butt several times, but Matt stayed alive by not finishing last. I believe it is wrong to say Matt won 10 duels. I think it is correct to say Matt did not lose 10 of his duels.