FANDOM


  • What are some good themed ideas for seasons of survivor. I.E. an all kid survivor ages 11-17 Dynamic duo survivor, some of the greatest two people alliances. Returning first eliminated players trying for a second chance at the title. Jeff Probst as a contestant?

      Loading editor
    • ALL KID SURVIVOR I am under 18 and want that!! I made up my own season once of that. And first-voted-out contestants. That would be fantastic.

        Loading editor
    • First boots season would be impossible as most of them are too old. Assuming Francesca is eligible and Tina/JFP are not, and further assuming no returnees are booted first in 27/28, that gives a total of 25 first boots - 28 if you stretch the definition a bit and include Jonathan/Wanda/Kourtney. To get 20 of them to come back would be impossible. And male/female balance would be even more impossible.

      All-kids is out for legal reasons. Though an Endurance revival is possible.

        Loading editor
    • All Winner season!!!

        Loading editor
    • Identical twins that could really mess with everyone's minds

        Loading editor
    • Kid Survivor! I used to have one with my class. I would so compete (and win) that :D

        Loading editor
    • Though this hasn't been talked about in a bit. I really wish there WAS a way for Kids to be on Survivor. How cool would that be? I know legal reasons is like they can't starve us or something right? Not really sure as to what the legal issues are. But if they were to do a Kid Survivor, the stakes for us would have to be so much easier (not as bad environment, more food/water, not as grueling challenges etc., shorter game-span (Not 39 Days?)

        Loading editor
    • maybe returning players, they haven't done that in a while

        Loading editor
    • Celebrity survivor would be awesome. 

        Loading editor
    • Second Chances is something I'd like to see, Which means pre jury castaways can have another chance to show that they can play the game given the opportunity. I mean look how Boston Rob & Monica improved. Although, A more unique choice would be Kids Survivor, Even if the law approved it, I'm not sure how many parents would let there kids do it.

        Loading editor
    • JuliaAndDanielle, my mom would be all for letting me apply. She's actually been wanting a Kid's Version for the sole reason that I'd play :P

        Loading editor
    • Bwburke94 wrote:
      First boots season would be impossible as most of them are too old. Assuming Francesca is eligible and Tina/JFP are not, and further assuming no returnees are booted first in 27/28, that gives a total of 25 first boots - 28 if you stretch the definition a bit and include Jonathan/Wanda/Kourtney. To get 20 of them to come back would be impossible. And male/female balance would be even more impossible.

      All-kids is out for legal reasons. Though an Endurance revival is possible.

      first boots can be done now, we now have enough male first boots.

      Also many female first boots are actually young and athletic,  The only first boots I think who cant play again will be Sonja and Jim.

      we can make it a 16 people cast or have extra females, I mean Fiji have more male contestants than female because Mellissa Quits before filming began.

        Loading editor
    • Idol Mania!!!

      Have a hand full of idols with different special powers with different time frames. Example: an idol that counts as an extra vote or negates a votes. Time Frame: 5 Tribal Councils.

        Loading editor
    • Have the final two each being able to boot someone off the jury. That way if they know someone isn't going to vote for them, that's one less vote against them.

        Loading editor
    • I would like to see challenges that go back to the survivor theme.The best Shelter. A fishing challenge. The most visible sos. The first to get fire. The most creative food ideas. A raft challenge.  Things you would really need to survive !!  It is also wonderful when people from the country are a little bit involved. (Like when Rupert stole the shoes to trade).

        Loading editor
    • A teen edition will be great of 13 to 17 years old. In the Philippines, Big Brother regularly holds teen editions. For Survivor US, I think this can be handled by adding some precautionary rules to the show like NO SEX, NO ALCOHOL, and other stuff. They can also include a former outcast from regular seasons as mentors. As well, the location can be an island in the US to ensure the safety of the teens.

        Loading editor
    • All Stars Season with all Seasons from 1 to 29 represented by one contestant.

      On the first day, there should be a major challenge where all the contestant will fight to get a spot on a tribe. The losing 11 castaways will have no tribes and will go home.

        Loading editor
    • Cellery108 wrote:
      Celebrity survivor would be awesome. 


      With Brains VS Brawns VS Beauty twist.

        Loading editor
    • I think child labor laws would prevent an all kid season. But the first ones out would make a good season. The only problem would be a lot of contestants voted out early are voted out because of their lack of physical strength, so we could end up with a season of lame players.

        Loading editor
    • Monmon298 wrote:
      All Stars Season with all Seasons from 1 to 29 represented by one contestant.

      On the first day, there should be a major challenge where all the contestant will fight to get a spot on a tribe. The losing 11 castaways will have no tribes and will go home.

      This would be really cool to have a starting challenge that eliminates players, but it's nice sometimes to watch the weak players play.

        Loading editor
    • The game could have puzzles in it.

        Loading editor
    • Or maybe a twist where they start with 5 tribes of 5(25 castaways), and at the start of the game a whole tribe gets eliminated leaving 20

        Loading editor
    • That's good, by I imagine an initial "blood bath" for the initial game where everyone are in their fittest self and are willing to give it all.

        Loading editor
    • What about Survivor Worldwide, previous castaways from international franchises are invited to the ultimate survivor. That would be awesome.

        Loading editor
    • Ohh, I like worldwide version. It'd be cool to watch the cultures mesh. And the fact that they don't all speak the same language would be hilarious. A tribe where none of them can aptly communicate. The disorganization would be beautiful. 

        Loading editor
    • It would also be cool to see various kinds of strategies that some might employ.

        Loading editor
    • Ideas I have had

      Do another Brains vs Brawns but ONLY brains and  brawns have it played in a Greek Island, tribe names Sparta (brawn) Athens (brains) And call it Survivor Greece LOL 

      Survivor Vietnam, based on the Vietnam war

      Survivor season where they are pitted against people they hate

      Survivor Rivals... you could bring back some of survivor's greatest rivals and have them face off... 

      Loser's edition, all players are pre jury/merge people like Robb Zbatnic and Cao Boi 

        Loading editor
    • I like the Loser Edition, there were amazing strategist that has actually never made it to the merge. Silas of Africa for example.

        Loading editor
    • I like the old school vs. new school idea. That way the old school will know more about the survival aspect and the pre-immunity idols while the new school will have an advantage with the twists and such. 

        Loading editor
    • Having a first boot season would be kinda strange because most people on couch would mostly be like "Who the h*ll is this" also Tina would be an early target.

        Loading editor
    • TheMysterious JonathanPenner
      TheMysterious JonathanPenner removed this reply because:
      It sucked
      21:21, August 26, 2014
      This reply has been removed
    • ^ Survivor Legends: In my mind 2 similar to HvV, but I see where you're coming from with the 4 tribes could be fun but I think it's way too soon for another all-returnee season

      Survivor Mix n' Match: Personally I like to see personalities clash so if they all have the same personalities some tribes will be very mellow while others will be overly amped up. Also a bit like BvBvB

      Survivor Celebrities: I think the Danish version is like this (or one of the foreign versions), fun but we see enough of celebrities already, also many of them wouldn't come due to loosing weight or muscle and having appearances ruined by the elements. 

      Survivor Mergeless: ehh, could be ok

      Survivor Tribeless: Imagine a tribal with 20 people… just no… Also it'd be hard to build a shelter for that many people.

        Loading editor
    • Survivor Rivals would be interesting.

      If Survivor: Losers consisted of pre-merge boots (rather than just first boots) it would be definitely possible and probably an amazing season.

      Here is my cast for Survivor: Losers

      Red Tribe:

      Alexis Maxwell (Cagayan)

      Ace Gordon (Gabon)

      Ashley Massaro (China)

      Jessie Camacho (Africa)

      Joel Anderson (Micronesia)

      Christine Shields Markowski (South Pacific)

      Wanda Shirk (Palau)

      Robb Zbacnik (Thailand)

      Joel Klug (Borneo)

      John Paylock (Vanuatu)


      Blue Tribe:

      Jonathan Libby (Palau)

      Francesca Hogi (Redemption Island & Caramoan)

      Jaquie Berg (Gabon)

      Stephanie Valencia (Redemption Island)

      Brian Corridan (Guatemala)

      Mikayla Wingle (South Pacific)

      J. P. Calderon (Cook Islands)

      Bill Posley (One World)

      Nicole Delma (Pearl Islands)

      Anthony Robinson (Fiji)

        Loading editor
    • No more hidden idols.

      In team challenges you have to nominate two people to be safe before each tribal council where those people wont be able to participate in tribal councils. like the opposite of exile island.

      But the ability to pass the individual immunity idol before the votes are read.

        Loading editor
    • I thought u could pass the idol b4 tribal, or play it for someone else. Didn't Malcolm play an idol for Eddie

        Loading editor
    • Correct... this change would allow all forms of individual immunity to be passed: the necklace, the idol, and the Tyler Perry idol. So it's a bit overpowered.

        Loading editor
    • I've got the winner, but not sure how to get it to CBS.  They really need to do a season with IDENTICAL TWINS.  Think of the possibilities~

        Loading editor
    • All identical twins could be cool, but very confusing to Jeff and the viewers. Also it really limits the casting possibility as they have ti be twins with both twins willing to play.


      But it'd be hilarious to watch those challenges and have no idea who to cheer for, and twins could find out what the other twin is doing by posing as them

        Loading editor
    • 204.14.22.145 wrote:
      I've got the winner, but not sure how to get it to CBS.  They really need to do a season with IDENTICAL TWINS.  Think of the possibilities~

      I'd be up for that.

        Loading editor
    • That season would be worst than Redemption Island...

        Loading editor
    • This is kinda random but why is jenna lewis so popular on the wiki now?

        Loading editor
    • I am over blood Vs. water...how about getting bitter enemies (in real life) to play?  Each contestant would have a bitter enemy or frenemie on the island, competing against them.

        Loading editor
    • Well, this will sound stupid, but a tribe swap every episode! Long term strategy is annihilated and episodes are more unpredictable hooray... Also, I just thought, what happens when you have a deadlocked three way tie at final six? So the other two make a fire? I'm curious lol

        Loading editor
    • 67.252.37.31 wrote:
      Well, this will sound stupid, but a tribe swap every episode! Long term strategy is annihilated and episodes are more unpredictable hooray... Also, I just thought, what happens when you have a deadlocked three way tie at final six? So the other two make a fire? I'm curious lol

      Deadlocked three-way tie at final six goes to rocks.

        Loading editor
    • How about this:

      Begin with four tribes of five each.

      After every Tribal Council, a tribe switch - reward challenge mix.

      No merge.

      A few examples include:

      Individual challenges, and the two, three, or four winners will win a better reward based on how they placed in the challenge, if a reward.

      Each tribe wins the reward challenge in order and elects one of their members to head to Exile Island. The people sent there will draw a new buff.

      Same as above, but the ones sent to Exile Island also compete in a mini-challenge there for an extra reward for their new tribe.

      Each tribe picks one person to leave their tribe and join a new one.

      The winning member of each challenge does the same as above.

      And more.

        Loading editor
    • 76.110.29.66 wrote: Idol Mania!!!

      Have a hand full of idols with different special powers with different time frames. Example: an idol that counts as an extra vote or negates a votes. Time Frame: 5 Tribal Councils.

      Great idea.

        Loading editor
    • how about a season with 1 tribe made up of survivors who made it really far into the game despite stuff like being on a weak tribe, or not being great in challenges or people trying to vote them out, ie 1 tribe with people like Spencer and Tasha from Cagayan, Laura from Samoa and Blood vs Water, Susie from Gabon, Stephanie from Palau, Guatemala and Heroes Vs Villains, Denise from Phillipines, Keith from San Juan Del Sur, Matty from redemption island, Ozzy, and maybe someone like Bob from Gabon or Chris from Vanuatu, Survivor against all odds

        Loading editor
    • I think one time players who made an impact, good or bad should be invited to come back, people like: -Ian (Palau) -Stephen (Tocatins) -Fabio (Nicaragua) -Todd (China) -Terry (Exile) -Spencer (Cagayan) -Kass (Cagayan) -Kenny (Gabon) -Crystal (Gabon) -Matty (Gabon) -Bob (Gabon) -Sophie (South Pacific)

      People like that. I guess there were a lot of strategic one time players from Gabon, funny.

        Loading editor
    • As tempting as it would be to watch Francesca be voted out first for a third time (which she probably wouldn't be amongst many other weaker members) we have a very limited number of male options for first voted out and should anyone be too old or not want to play again, we might not have enough. Not to mention most of the first votes are weak and/or annoying and not necessarily the most strategic either. Solid concept but too many things working against it.

      To make things more competitive challenge-wise what about a "Challenge masters" edition? The most successful individual immunity/redemption island players from each season. Kelly, Colby, Lex, Kathy, Brian, Jenna, Burton, Boston Rob (Not him since he's played 4 times), Chris, Tom, Danni, Terry, Ozzy, Boo, Amanda, Erik, Bob, JT, Brett, Parvati, Fabio, Matt, Ozzy (obviously he couldn't be in twice), Kim, Malcolm, Cochran, Laura, Spencer, and Keith. Removing Boston Rob and one of the Ozzys that leaves 27 proven strong competitors, many of whom were strategic and social threats as well, and most of whom would likely appreciate another shot.

        Loading editor
    • So I was thinking about an idea the other day. The producers of Survivor have mentioned on numerous occasions that they would like to do another season in Australia, but can't because it would be too expensive. I've come up with an idea about how they could do this.

      For one season only (unless it works well and they decide to do it again), they partner with an Australian production company (or the Nine Network, which owns the broadcast rights in Australia) who will pick-up part of the tab it would cost to make in Australia. So they turn it into a co-production.

      The issue would be "how do we convince an Austrailan company to do a US show?" Simple! I present to you….


      SURVIVOR: Home and Away (Although this might need to be changed so the producers don't get in trouble with a particular Aussie soap opera.)

      The concept:

      Set in Australia, two teams arrive on the first day. The first team made of typical Survivor contestants. Loud, outspoken, strategy minded, you name it, they're there.

      The second is a tribe of Australian contestants. That's right, an Australian tribe faces against a US tribe. 

      The "question" (which the producers seem to like having) this season would ask, "In Survivor, could there be such a thing as a home advantage?"


      Here some other ideas.

      For one tribal challenge, teams must nominate one player to complete in a challenge with out knowing what the challenge is. Do they select someone who is strong physically and find out it's a mental based challenge? Do they send a someone who has the brains, only to find out it's an endurance challenge?

      The Hidden in plain sight Immunity Idol.

      What if for one season the torches were the hidden immunity idols? Hear me out, basically everyone doesn't realise that they all, in essence, have immunity. The catch, it can only be used once during the game, so once someone plays it (basically, the first to figure it out) then no one else can do it. Sort of a first come, first served idea. Imagine, the contestants shock when they realise all this time they had all been going to tribal with immunity, quite safe if only they had played it. I guess it's almost like the producers are blindsiding the contestants.

      An Easy/Hard challenge

      Tribes are given the choice between two options, One is much easier to do, but takes a long time. The other is much more harder, but if done correctly can be done in a much shorter time. What will they choose to do?

      Stay tuned, more to come.

        Loading editor
    • Oops, forgot to log in. I'm claiming the above comment as mine.

        Loading editor
    • Bwburke, but I thought that if the vote deadlocks and only two people are left without exemption, then you'd build a fire? The I.C. winner and the three in the deadlock would be immune, so the other two would make a fire, right?

        Loading editor
    • people playing for their fourth time vs people playing for their third time vs people playing for their fifth time

        Loading editor
    • I would honestly like to see a BrainsBrawnBeauty season with returning players !! That'l be great i think 

        Loading editor
    • I just hope they dont make a Gay Guys Vs Straight Guys Vs Lesbian Girls Vs Straight Girls

      That would be aweful lol !

        Loading editor
    • 60.48.176.113 wrote:
      I just hope they dont make a Gay Guys Vs Straight Guys Vs Lesbian Girls Vs Straight Girls

      That would be aweful lol !

      I would imagine after the negative reception of the Season 13 racial division they'd be hesitant to consider such a controversial division. They'd likely lose a significant number of viewers in the gay community and southern states.

        Loading editor
    • 10 Dominant Players against 10Weak Players


      Winners vs. Runner-Ups


      All Survivors return

        Loading editor
    • First, two random comments: 1: I was watching Jeopardy and this woman said she does survivor podcasts and i was yelling at everyone in the room to be quiet and 2 why is cecilia from cook islands sopopular right now??

      Morgan

      Cirie

      Shirin

      Natalie B

      Jenna M

      Kim

      Abi Maria

      Baylor 

      Colleen

      Ciera

      Rich

      JT

      Shane

      Earl

      Hayden 

      Reed

      Troyzan

      Marty

      Kenny

      Sean 

      If anyone wants to organize these people into tribes feel free 

        Loading editor
    • maybe a freaks vs weirdos season?

      freaks are people with jobs like clown or circus performer anything like that

      weirdos are nerds, geeks anything like that

        Loading editor
    • ErinandtheTIGERS wrote:
      maybe a freaks vs weirdos season?

      freaks are people with jobs like clown or circus performer anything like that

      weirdos are nerds, geeks anything like that

      And you don't think people would be offended by that?

        Loading editor
    • Clay Thompson wrote:
      ErinandtheTIGERS wrote:
      maybe a freaks vs weirdos season?

      freaks are people with jobs like clown or circus performer anything like that

      weirdos are nerds, geeks anything like that

      And you don't think people would be offended by that?

      Agreed but I can so see them doing that for like season 32

        Loading editor
    • ok so funny jobs vs serious jobs

      funny jobs are clowns and comedian

      serious jobs are like teachers and military leaders

        Loading editor
    • This might be an idea. How about a season with 2 games going on at once. 32 contestants split into 4 tribes but a tribe is only competing against one other tribe, and no one knows there is 2 games going on at once. Then when both games get down to 10 each, they have the merge, and then at the first immunity challenge there is a surprise, that one new merged tribe sees the other tribe walk up the beach, and everyone's shocked. Then jeff reveals that it is not merge, these 2 tribes will compete again as tribes until they reach final 10. And then they finally merge for real.

        Loading editor
    • Unfortunately, kids could never happen. Do we want the same legal mess that followed Kid Nation? Even if they did succeed in convincing people it was safe, lawsuits could endanger the series as a whole. Producers don't want to risk it.

      Maybe another Redemption Island season, except instead of one person returning at merge, someone would return every two episodes. For example, Bob gets voted out ep. 1. Sue gets voted out ep. 2. Bob and Sue compete at Redemption, and Bob wins. Bob returns ep. 3. However, they would only get three chances, so if Bob was voted out twice more he would be gone. Sure, it would be long, but it would be cool too! 

        Loading editor
    • Survivor: Battle of the Queens -one tribe full of meghan trainors

      -one tribe full of beyonces

      -one tribe full of brenda lowes

        Loading editor
    • Survivorpanda wrote:
      Survivor: Battle of the Queens

      -one tribe full of meghan trainors

      -one tribe full of beyonces

      -one tribe full of brenda lowes

      Obviously this was an attempt at a joke. It failed. Miserably.

        Loading editor
    • 100.3.224.142 wrote:
      Survivorpanda wrote:
      Survivor: Battle of the Queens

      -one tribe full of meghan trainors

      -one tribe full of beyonces

      -one tribe full of brenda lowes

      Obviously this was an attempt at a joke. It failed. Miserably.

      1. no, it was not a joke

      2. make an account

      3. you are jealous of meghan trainor, beyonce, and brenda lowe

        Loading editor
    • Survivorpanda wrote:
      100.3.224.142 wrote:
      Survivorpanda wrote:
      Survivor: Battle of the Queens

      -one tribe full of meghan trainors

      -one tribe full of beyonces

      -one tribe full of brenda lowes

      Obviously this was an attempt at a joke. It failed. Miserably.
      1. no, it was not a joke

      2. make an account

      3. you are jealous of meghan trainor, beyonce, and brenda lowe


      this could be made into a rich vs poor season

        Loading editor
    • If they do second chances it must include Alexis Maxwell and Kelley Wentworth

        Loading editor
    • SteelWolf wrote:
      If they do second chances it must include Alexis Maxwell and Kelley Wentworth

      and ace and edgardo

        Loading editor
    • Prsonally, I think the race twist of Cook Islands was not controversial 

      So, All-Star 2.0 but divided by race (could not have competed in HvV)


      Must inlude Shii Ann and Natalie A

        Loading editor
    • Coolboy18 wrote:
      Prsonally, I think the race twist of Cook Islands was not controversial 

      So, All-Star 2.0 but divided by race (could not have competed in HvV)


      Must inlude Shii Ann and Natalie A

      It may not have been controversial then, but it would be now. I think it would be cool but...

      If they were to do it again, I think they should do it with a fresh cast, not All-Stars.

        Loading editor
    • How cool it would be, if all survivors came with a partner, but no one knew who each other partners were. Basically you would have a secret alliance. You could choose to share your secret while making new alliances. You and your partner could pretend to not like each other and share secrets. Think of the blindsides that could happen. The possibility's are endless!!

        Loading editor
    • Survivor: Israel- The Holy Land

      tribe camps on the Sea of Galilee, desert-ish, immunity idol is a golden calf, tribal council is a tabernacle

        Loading editor
    • 68.191.80.52 wrote: How cool it would be, if all survivors came with a partner, but no one knew who each other partners were. Basically you would have a secret alliance. You could choose to share your secret while making new alliances. You and your partner could pretend to not like each other and share secrets. Think of the blindsides that could happen. The possibility's are endless!!

      That's such a cool idea, and it would be really cool to see how it turns out

        Loading editor
    • Surferdude1219 wrote:

      68.191.80.52 wrote: How cool it would be, if all survivors came with a partner, but no one knew who each other partners were. Basically you would have a secret alliance. You could choose to share your secret while making new alliances. You and your partner could pretend to not like each other and share secrets. Think of the blindsides that could happen. The possibility's are endless!!

      That's such a cool idea, and it would be really cool to see how it turns out

      didn't that happen on Big Brother?

        Loading editor
    • 24.190.117.203 wrote:
      This might be an idea. How about a season with 2 games going on at once. 32 contestants split into 4 tribes but a tribe is only competing against one other tribe, and no one knows there is 2 games going on at once. Then when both games get down to 10 each, they have the merge, and then at the first immunity challenge there is a surprise, that one new merged tribe sees the other tribe walk up the beach, and everyone's shocked. Then jeff reveals that it is not merge, these 2 tribes will compete again as tribes until they reach final 10. And then they finally merge for real.


      Wow! Thats really a cool idea. If there is going to be 4 or moretribes with ALL returning players, it's best to categorize them, i.e HvV 1 game and the other game could be BvBvB returning players or something like that 

        Loading editor
    • Sorry for off topic thing but wheel of fortune just has an extremely easy Survivor puzzle

        Loading editor
    • I had an idea while watching Joe get voted off. I love him but I could see he would never make it to the end, I mean who would want to go against him right? Especially because this year everyone is super competitive and really wants to win at any cost. That got me thinking about my favorite, Ozzy and how he could never be taken to the end either unless he was strong enough to survive the challenges and he proved it probably can't be done. So, how about a season where all of the contestants are all star good guys/girls...all those super fit and likable all stars who would be immediate targets on any other all star show. You know on a regular season, the first half all the weak and old get voted off and then after the merge the strongest and the nicest are targets....well, what if they are all strong and nice!!! Also, it would force some of the players we think are so sweet and innocent really have to get their hands dirty for once.

        Loading editor
    • While it would make for some epic challenges, I feel like it would limit the diversity of the cast in a negative way, if they can even find a whole cast of them. Especially if they must be (presumably physical, not mental) challenge threats, physically fit and/or attractive, fairly young, and nice. Incidentally Ozzy probably wouldn't match those criteria as he's not exactly the nicest guy out there. Certainly not the meanest, but in all of his seasons there have been more friendly males. Joe would fit these requirements, as would Malcolm Freberg, Matt Elrod, maybe Fabio and J.T. (although they both won). On the women's side you have Tasha Fox, Kim Spradlin (another winner)...I just don't see that many people who fit all the personality, age, physical appearance and demonstrated physical challenge abilities (even if mental challenge threats are included, which in all probability don't fit all those requirements either) AND on top of that have not won AND can still fulfill the requirements as successfully as their initial season. Take Colby, for example-Impressive in S2, less so in S8, and in S20 he was...to quote James..."Superman in a fat suit" and was considered so little of a threat he was the last of his tribe to be voted out.

        Loading editor
    • Cirieandrudy wrote:
      people playing for their fourth time vs people playing for their third time vs people playing for their fifth time

      This couldn't work because the only people to play four times were Boston Rob and Rupert and no one has played five times and I really don't want to see these two again. They had their shot four times. Love them, but we need to get more people on the board. 

        Loading editor
    • Now that 30 seasons have passed we can really do old school vs. new school. seasons 1-15 are old school and seasons 16-30 are new school. 

      This might be cool because people who haven't played in a longtime might have some advantages in survival and must adapt to the newer elements of the game, while the newer members might have to adapt to the survival elements. Also, the old schoolers have had a longer chance to strategize as they have been out of the game long enough to know how to fix what they messed up their last season, so they might try extra hard to make sure this season they'll get it right. 

        Loading editor
    • Republicans vs democrats vs third party

        Loading editor
    • i can see cbs do this

      8 random people vs 8 random returning players vs boston rob

      in a twist, the game will go on and boston rob will get in the game on day 39, and as a reward, he will get +12 jury votes.

        Loading editor
    • New rule: After every Immunity challenge, they hold Tribal Council immediately.  No chance to co-ordinate votes.

      New rule: No idol of any kind can be played at a Tribal Council where the person with Immunity gives the necklace back to Jeff.

      New rule: Advantages bought at Survivor Auctions are fixed-price items, no more than, say, $250.  Everyone who wants in will draw rocks to see who gets it.  The rock lottery winner is, thereafter, out of the auction.

      Now here are some season ideas, although a few of them are clearly just for laughs:

      Survivor: Turf Wars - Tribes are divided according to "turf," that is, the part of the country they are from (Northeast vs. South vs. Midwest vs. West).

      Survivor: Money Between Friends - Like Blood vs. Water, but with each player paired with a best friend.

      Survivor: Return to Redemption Island - This time, both tribes vote someone out every Tribal Council, then castoffs battle for elimination every single episode.  Winner joins the opposite tribe from where they just got booted from.  Repeat until the merge.  Then, after the merge, every person voted off gets to take someone with them. Players are, therefore, careful who they vote out.  Also, they cannot "take with them" someone they just tried to vote out.  Redemption duels continue as before, until the Final Five, which becomes like the "two-minute warning," in that from that point on, only one person is voted out at a time and sent directly to the jury until the finals.

      Survivor: Comedy vs. Drama - All-star edition featuring players known for bringing comic relief versus players that brought a lot of drama.

      Survivor: Oregon Trail - A lot of players may surely be medically evacuated due to dysentery.

      Survivor: The Ark - 40 days, 40 nights, 18 castaways, one Survivor.

      Survivor: New World - Twelve players compete until they're down to eight, then eight more players move onto the beach and join the game anew.  Might work if it's an All-Star season where eight players are given byes via an online fan vote.

      Survivor: Enemies - Every player is paired with someone they hate; yet their fortunes in the game are directly tied to their respective enemy's success.  In short, a player wins half of whatever their "partner" wins.  If one player wins the $1 million, then that player's enemy wins $500,000.  If a player finishes second, then that player's enemy also receives half of the second prize amount for that season.  This is in addition to any awards the players might receive on their own.

      Survivor: Hunger Games - The game begins at a giant cornucopia, with tribe members gathering as many supplies as they can for their tribe in two minutes or less.  Players also try to shoot the other tribe's players with paintballs. Tribe with the fewest players who've been shot, or last tribe standing, wins all the supplies that their unscathed members have in hand.  Also, every time someone is voted out, Jeff fires a cannon to alert the immune tribe of what just happened.

        Loading editor
    • Love Survivor: The Ark idea. They should set it in Turkey, near Mount Ararat. Use the Noah's Ark set from Burnetts series "The Bible" for Tribal. Get the tribes to tend for a group of animals, including finding enough food for them. If an animal dies, they vote one player off and their camp is stripped of any shelters and supplies they might have.

      How about Survivor: The Reversal? We put 18 or however many on the one beach. Rewards are won for the whole camp by completing tasks/challenges within a set time. (We could have an awesome hour glass for this.)

      Once we ht the final 6, the current jury vote for who goes to which of the two newly formed tribes. These tribes go to new camps, so neither get an unfair advantage. As for all the supplies, these get auctioned off at an impromptu Survivor auction straight after the split. The hidden immunity idols could, like a previous comment I have made, be hidden in plain sight. For example they are the torches, but it can only be used once. So if you work out the torch is the idol, you can keep it to yourself, or tell someone at the risk of them playing the idol before you have the chance. Instead of clues to the location, they are given riddles  which allude to the fact in a round about way. They could even place fake idols around, telling the contestants that some of the idols hidden around camp are fakes and they need to make certain the idol they have is the real deal. Otherwise, if they play an official "fake idol" they receive an extra vote against them.

        Loading editor
    • Why do I always forget to log in? The above was me.

        Loading editor
    • Survivor: Students of the Game: Everyone's favorite Survivor nerds compete to win the million. I can see Stephen Fishback, Shirin, Max, etc.

      Survivor: Battle of the Evil People... Or something: Greatest villains of all time compete!

        Loading editor
    • I just want to put a twist out there. Kind of like the outcasts, the first 6 eliminated people vote for someone to get immunity at the merge.

        Loading editor
    • Just three random ideas I had

      1) 20 people start, two get voted out immedeatly (like in tocantins) but they don't leave the game entirely, they return at the day of the merge, so they can shake things up and have their revenge on their tribe, or forgive them.

      2) The people who were already voted out can occasionaly come back into challenges, not to compete, but to help and advise some tribe/person or try to sabotage their game (not in any drastic way of course, like challenge advantages that can be won or bought already)

      3) At the last day of the game the final two/three leave the island after the remembering of the other players and the final tribal councel with all talking and voting takes place AFTER the season airs, before the reunion. I think it would result in much more deserved victory, because both people and the jury would see the entire game from all perspectives and really see who is the better player and who deserves to win

        Loading editor
    • 89.176.63.75 wrote:
      Just three random ideas I had

      1) 20 people start, two get voted out immedeatly (like in tocantins) but they don't leave the game entirely, they return at the day of the merge, so they can shake things up and have their revenge on their tribe, or forgive them.

      2) The people who were already voted out can occasionaly come back into challenges, not to compete, but to help and advise some tribe/person or try to sabotage their game (not in any drastic way of course, like challenge advantages that can be won or bought already)

      3) At the last day of the game the final two/three leave the island after the remembering of the other players and the final tribal councel with all talking and voting takes place AFTER the season airs, before the reunion. I think it would result in much more deserved victory, because both people and the jury would see the entire game from all perspectives and really see who is the better player and who deserves to win

      1. This is basically a combination of the Schoolyard Pick Elimination from Palau and the Outcasts twist from Pearl Islands, both of which are generally looked down upon as terrible. Also as in the Outcasts twist, the two people are either going to be voted out or spurned by the jury unless they somehow both make it to a final 2 together.

      2. Is this newbie season? If so I'm not sure how useful the advice of two people who have never played and presumably have some sort of obvious flaw that made them first boots at the start. You've heard of "the blind leading the blind?" This is kind of ike the blind leading the moderately vision-impaired.

      3. While this would certainly make the end result more "fair" to the finalists, there are a few reasons it might not work. Firstly, it would completely overturn at least 30 seasons' worth of tradition. This is more of a reason why it would likely never happen on the show than a strike against it as a concept, but it should be mentioned. Secondly, part of the challenge of the game is to convince people within the game that you should win at the finals. When the jury's initial perspective is altered by the producers' editing it could be an issue because there are often "Winner's edits" given to people to make them look good, and these may conflict with reality somewhat. Finally, are you unsatisfied with most of the winners we've had these past 30 seasons? For me personally I would replace Amber with Rob, Natalie with Russell, Sandra with Parvati, and Fabio with Sash (although tbh I didn't think anyone from Nicaragua's finals should've been there). 4 out of 30 is a pretty good record for the current form of voting, and had people been given time to watch the season I think all of those votes would have ended up exactly the same. I don't know how often you've felt a different finalist should win, but I doubt it's more than 10/30.

        Loading editor
    • SteelWolf wrote: If they do second chances it must include Alexis Maxwell and Kelley WENTWORTH

      Mhm

        Loading editor
    • 22 people. 3 tribes of 7 with one person not getting picked like in Palau.

        Loading editor
    • This is probably bad, but left-handed people vs. right-handed people vs. ambidextrous people? IDK :P

        Loading editor
    • Iloveschool71 wrote:
      This is probably bad, but left-handed people vs. right-handed people vs. ambidextrous people? IDK :P

      Why do people always feel the need to have themed seasons be three tribes?

        Loading editor
    • Bwburke94 wrote:

      Why do people always feel the need to have themed seasons be three tribes?

      A lot of themes just work better that way. The Collars theme works better as White/Blue/No than with just White/Blue, for example. Heroes vs Villains and Fans vs Favorites obviously make more sense in a two-tribe format, and Brains vs Brawn seems feasible, (although personally I prefer the three-tribe format for that as well) but many themes seem incomplete with just two.

        Loading editor
    • The only reason I'd like to see a left vs. right vs. ambidextrous season is because it increases my change of showing up for a BvW a year later, because my brother is ambidextrous.

        Loading editor
    • I have an idea!! :) A second chance season!! But we get to make the cast ^_^

        Loading editor
    • Survivorpanda wrote: I have an idea!! :) A second chance season!! But we get to make the cast ^_^

      Love that idea... only problem is, there is some one-time players we want to see again (like Colleen Haskell) that will never return; it's defiantly a good idea though.

        Loading editor
    • Another idea.

      20 people with three tribes, from a pick'em. The two captains each choose 6 people in a schoolyard pick, and the remaining 6 become the "third" tribe but are automatically immune at the first Tribal Council.

        Loading editor
    • I've toyed around with the idea of an idol called the "Sole Idol", which allows the user to cast the sole vote to eliminate. Must be played before final 6, only available after the merge. I've also thought it would be cool if one of the mystery items at an auction was that the buyer would automatically get eliminated from the game.

        Loading editor
    • Iloveschool71 wrote:
      I've also thought it would be cool if one of the mystery items at an auction was that the buyer would automatically get eliminated from the game.

      Kass, is that you?

        Loading editor
    • Bwburke94 wrote:

      Iloveschool71 wrote:
      I've also thought it would be cool if one of the mystery items at an auction was that the buyer would automatically get eliminated from the game.

      Kass, is that you?

      xD

        Loading editor
    • How about a Winners vs. Celebrities? Ten pervious Survivor winners against ten celebrities. If a former Survivor winner wins again, they win $2 Million, but if a celebrity wins, they win $1 Million for the charity of their choice.

        Loading editor
    • How about Survivor Apocalypse  set in a abandon area like a old ship yard  where food and other things needed to survive are hidden threw out the rubble of the buildings. There was a TV show  The Clooney it only arid 2 times but combine its concept with the survivor game. With all the zombie  stuff out there use that type setting  but with out the zombies.I know if you did I would surly watch it and would love to be in it 

        Loading editor
    • As a huge fan from "down under". (Australia, that is!)

      I would love to see, what I'd imagine would pan out to be an incredibly fascinating season to watch.......Australia V America. In other words "The Aussies V Yankees". Two competitive nations come together for the ultimate battle of Survivor!

        Loading editor
    • I thought of an idea that might be interesting but could backfire hugely...

      Maybe make it so that every other episode new teams are picked (i.e. episodes with an odd number of people). One Team Captain (decided by a challenge?) would pick, followed by another Captain. The people they picked would pick next, and so on. The person not picked would be eliminated. All the other episodes would have a typical format, with an Immunity Challenge and Tribal Council. This new format would bring new powers to alliances and would make it somewhat more interesting in terms of "making big moves". Do you risk it and pick the person who everyone wants eliminated, or do you bend to your alliances wishes? After the merge it would return entirely to the standard theme. This could potentially be used in tandem with Redemption Island, though they should try it once without first.

        Loading editor
    • My idea would be more immunity from challenges.

      For the opposing tribe portion of the game, the individuals on the losing tribe would participate in a separate immunity challenge, granting one of the players going into tribal council protection.

      When reaching the individual portion, split people into the smallest team number possible, with all members of the winning team receiving immunity. For anyone left vulnerable, provide a separate challenge (as in the tribe portion), to grant one extra person immunity. Say the merge happens at 12 remaining castaways:
      12: 1 team of 2 wins, 1 other person wins (3 immune, 9 not)
      11: 1 person wins (1 immune, 10 not)
      10: 1 team of 2 wins, 1 other person wins (3 immune, 7 not)
      9: 1 team of 3 wins, 1 other person wins (4 immune, 5 not)
      8: 1 team of 2 wins, 1 other wins (3 immune, 5 not)
      7: 1 person wins (1 immune, 6 not)
      6: 1 team of 2 wins, 1 other person wins (3 immune, 3 not)
      5: 1 person wins (1 immune, 4 not)

      This process may extend to 7 remaining castaways or to 5, and may or may not be played with idols (if played with idols, I would end this challenge generosity at 7).

      This style would provide the opportunity for a person to protect themselves from a failing tribe in the initial stage (and might encourage OR deter people from throwing a challenge). It would also allow complexity at the individual stage because a person partnered with a person on the bottom has a critical choice to make (try to win immunity for themselves and upset their alliance or risk vulnerability to satisfy the alliance). Likewise, the extra challenge afterward prevents a full sabotage of a team member's chances. Note that if a duo/trio of those on the bottom wins, a wrench is thrown in the dominant alliance's gameplay. Furthermore, the varying number of immune people per week would be something new contestants would never expect.

        Loading editor
    • I have 2 ideas:

      >Idol Island: Returnees that were voted out because of an idol. Maybe because someone said you had an idol, or because someone used it and backfired on you. Any survivor that ended up been eliminated because an idol was involved. Also, "Idol Island" would be an Exile Island spin-off: Instead of sending a player to Exile from the losing tribe , the winning tribe gets to select one player to Idol Island, an isolated place where several hidden immunity idols are hides. Some of them are useless, but others have special powers, and one of them could be a Special Idol (like in Cagayan). Players can only leave Idol Island with one idol at the time, and they once they open the idol's cover, they would know if it's a good one (because of the letter) or a fake one.

      >Second Chance, Winners vs Runner-ups: 10 formers sole survivors against 10 former runner-ups. Will history repeat for a winner, or a runner-up will rise victoriously and finish what they started?

        Loading editor
    • Rivals would be fun, we would pit people who notoriously hated eachother on opposing tribes. Inspired by people like: Courtney and Jean Robert, Phillip and Francessca, Abi and Denise, Dreamz and Yau Man, etc. 

        Loading editor
    • I think the new season should be called True Survivor.  Have 2 teams and give them absolutely nothing except a coach.  The 2 coaches would be  Bear Grylls and Les Stroud.  The coaches would not participate in challenges nor would they vote and they could not be voted out.   Now that would be Survivor!

        Loading editor
    • Themes: 

      I also think that it would be cool to see some people from various reality shows compete on survivor. It would be a season specifically dedicated to shows like, The Amazing Race, Big Brother and the Bachelor, etc. While a few returning survivor contestants can be sprinkled throughout the competition. I feel as though, the survivor contestants would have a strong bond as this is the show they know and love, while the newbies would bond as well. It would definitely be interesting!   

        Loading editor
    • An idea for a season could be 20 castaways are instantly merged and must play on an individual level. This would be all out war. Maybe there is a final 2 with 18 jury members. Wouldn't it be cool if the first boot made the merge and the jury? Or we could make the jury out of 17 people to prevent final 2 ties. Or instant merge and the jury consists of 9,10,or 11 people (like a normal season)

        Loading editor
    • Freddyfazbearisboss wrote:
      An idea for a season could be 20 castaways are instantly merged and must play on an individual level. This would be all out war. Maybe there is a final 2 with 18 jury members. Wouldn't it be cool if the first boot made the merge and the jury? Or we could make the jury out of 17 people to prevent final 2 ties. Or instant merge and the jury consists of 9,10,or 11 people (like a normal season)

      All new people for this and make this season consists of people above the age of 39 to see how many viewers the show would get without the young people that are easy on the eyes.

        Loading editor
    • My cousin aunt and I brain stormed an awesome idea! After last season's unique voting blocks we came up with an idea to eliminate tribes. Start the season with everyone on the same island. Each immunity challenge the group is split into two teams, like post-merg reward challenges, and the losing team from that week goes to tribal. This would mix things up each week and bring back the unique diversity of the "voting blocks" style. This will not only mix things up exponentially, but will also force a stronger social game!

        Loading editor
    • Survivorpanda wrote:
      maybe returning players, they haven't done that in a while

      You're kidding right? They literally just did that in seasons 27 and 31

        Loading editor
    • Icetower42 wrote:

      Survivorpanda wrote:
      maybe returning players, they haven't done that in a while

      You're kidding right? They literally just did that in seasons 27 and 31

      Last season was returning players... "Fan favorite". Do you even watch?!

        Loading editor
    • Jennistud wrote:
      My cousin aunt and I brain stormed an awesome idea! After last season's unique voting blocks we came up with an idea to eliminate tribes. Start the season with everyone on the same island. Each immunity challenge the group is split into two teams, like post-merg reward challenges, and the losing team from that week goes to tribal. This would mix things up each week and bring back the unique diversity of the "voting blocks" style. This will not only mix things up exponentially, but will also force a stronger social game!

      This isn't Pirate Master.

        Loading editor
    • I have an idea:


      Survivor: 1 Real Idol.

      When the Hidden Immunity Idol is found, three idols will be included in that hiding spot, but the twist: only one of them is real, the other two are fakes. All three idols all look similar, but the real one will have blue eyes (blue representing good) while the fakes will have red eyes on one and black eyes on the other one (red and black representing evil). The contestant can only take one idol and put the other two idols they didn't pick back in their hiding spot.

        Loading editor
    • TribalChants wrote:
      I have an idea:


      Survivor: 1 Real Idol.

      When the Hidden Immunity Idol is found, three idols will be included in that hiding spot, but the twist: only one of them is real, the other two are fakes. All three idols all look similar, but the real one will have blue eyes (blue representing good) while the fakes will have red eyes on one and black eyes on the other one (red and black representing evil). The contestant can only take one idol and put the other two idols they didn't pick back in their hiding spot.

      Hm. Obviously the contestants can't be told that blue = real, but this seems reasonable. The risk is that no one finds the real one and the season is a boring pagonging.

        Loading editor
    • Idea 1: Make the flint the hidden immunity idol. Do you give up your easy method of making fire and popularity in the tribe for a few more nights at camp? 

      Idea 2: Hide the immunity idol at tribal council.

      Idea 3: Have camp away from the shore or river e.t.c. They get water in the well, so the only issue would be if they want to get fish. Plus it means that people would get a better chance to look for the idol whilst others are off getting food.

      Random thought. The tribe are at camp for up to 39 days. Why do they only ever build a fairly basic shelter? Why doesn't someone create a larger structure? Start with the basic one we are used to, but then add onto it as the game progresses.

        Loading editor
    • ThatHuman wrote:
      Idea 3: Have camp away from the shore or river etc. They get water in the well, so the only issue would be if they want to get fish. Plus it means that people would get a better chance to look for the idol whilst others are off getting food.

      This is actually a decent idea.

        Loading editor
    • Bwburke94 wrote:
      ThatHuman wrote:
      Idea 3: Have camp away from the shore or river etc. They get water in the well, so the only issue would be if they want to get fish. Plus it means that people would get a better chance to look for the idol whilst others are off getting food.
      This is actually a decent idea.


      Cheers! (Jeff Probst, Mark Burnett, Take note. :) )

        Loading editor
    • ThatHuman wrote:
      Idea 1: Make the flint the hidden immunity idol. Do you give up your easy method of making fire and popularity in the tribe for a few more nights at camp? 

      This idea is brilliant! Maybe there could be a flint given out to one person selected to be sent to camp early by a vote like Worlds Apart/Cagayan etc. and that person could be given the choice of whether to keep the flint for themselves as an idol or share it with the tribe and maybe it loses it's power? Because the only issue with giving it out as the standard flint is that the idols all have to come with the official paper w/ idol rules and it's not like there's enough room to hide that inside a flint.

        Loading editor
    • Clay Thompson wrote:
      ThatHuman wrote:
      Idea 1: Make the flint the hidden immunity idol. Do you give up your easy method of making fire and popularity in the tribe for a few more nights at camp? 
      This idea is brilliant! Maybe there could be a flint given out to one person selected to be sent to camp early by a vote like Worlds Apart/Cagayan etc. and that person could be given the choice of whether to keep the flint for themselves as an idol or share it with the tribe and maybe it loses it's power? Because the only issue with giving it out as the standard flint is that the idols all have to come with the official paper w/ idol rules and it's not like there's enough room to hide that inside a flint.

      There would have to be special provisions for if someone else uses the "flint"/idol as actual flint, as they can't be told the twist ahead of time and flint isn't a personal possession.

      Because firemaking scenes are always filmed, production would know if the flint idol was used by someone other than the person sent to camp. The idol-holder would probably receive a more legitimate-looking idol in that case.

        Loading editor
    • Ok we need a new heros vs villins

        Loading editor
    • My idea for a Survivor season is 'Survivor Replay' a particular season is replayed with all the same contestants but this time they know who betrayed them, who was an ally to them, who was a threat and who made the final! Will the winner be eliminated first, or will everyone try to create an alliance with them?

        Loading editor
    • Survivor Chaos: featuring some of the most notorius, chaos seeking or "off the rocker" "annoying" contestants ever. These contestants vary from being stone cold ruthless, to being the annoying person at camp. Either way it would make for a great season. 

        Loading editor
    • They could do a season with contestant's from international versions of Survivor to compete on the American version (i.e. a contestant from the Swedish version "Expedition Robinson") with a fan vote to decide which international Survivor contestant competes on the American version.

        Loading editor
    • ThatHuman wrote:

      Idea 2: Hide the immunity idol at tribal council.

      I've also thought the same thing. However, it must be somewhere near the common areas, in order to avoid having the survivors romming around Tribal Council. For example, it could be hidden at the voting room, or near Jeff's spot.

      Also, there must be a rule that determines if a player grabs an item and uses it as an idol and it's not, that player can't try to grab another.

        Loading editor
    • Iloveschool71 wrote:
      I've toyed around with the idea of an idol called the "Sole Idol", which allows the user to cast the sole vote to eliminate. Must be played before final 6, only available after the merge. I've also thought it would be cool if one of the mystery items at an auction was that the buyer would automatically get eliminated from the game.

      I like that idea! However, a Sole Vote could be a overpowerfull twist. So, I thought that the Sole Vote could have two rules:

      - If the Sole Vote is played, that player can't use a Hidden Immunity Idol.

      - The Sole Vote can only be succesfully played if the mayority votes casted is not against that player. That gives the opportunity to void the Sole Vote if a player brags about having it, and allows the others players to vote and not expect the twist.

        Loading editor
    • Sole vote before Day 38 is too overpowered to work.

        Loading editor
    • 24.190.117.203 wrote:
      This might be an idea. How about a season with 2 games going on at once. 32 contestants split into 4 tribes but a tribe is only competing against one other tribe, and no one knows there is 2 games going on at once. Then when both games get down to 10 each, they have the merge, and then at the first immunity challenge there is a surprise, that one new merged tribe sees the other tribe walk up the beach, and everyone's shocked. Then jeff reveals that it is not merge, these 2 tribes will compete again as tribes until they reach final 10. And then they finally merge for real.

      I've also thought about that. But, maybe 32 players and two tribal councils per night would be hard to edit, in order to have the general idea of what's happening on each game. Maybe having 24 players, and doing the first "merge" at 20 or 18.

      Could be called "Old World VS. New World", a reference to the Spanish Conquers, when they came to Latinamerica.

        Loading editor
    • For starting tribes I would like to see randomised tribes (not like SJDS were the tribes were already selected) or a schoolyard pick.

        Loading editor
    • They should have a season where the cast is made of entirely of people that were previously medically evacuated or evacuated early because of other reasons.

        Loading editor
    • Jendav wrote:
      They should have a season where the cast is made of entirely of people that were previously medically evacuated or evacuated early because of other reasons.


      Alright then, what's a good 16-18 person cast for that season?

        Loading editor
    • Jendav wrote:
      They should have a season where the cast is made of entirely of people that were previously medically evacuated or evacuated early because of other reasons.

      There's nowhere near enough women for such a season.

      Kourtney Moon (Evac)

      Melissa McNulty-Sort of counts as an evac? But she never actually played and I doubt Casting would want her back after she screwed up the original plan for Fiji at the last minute.

      And that's it...so unless you want a season that's 90% men it wouldn't work.

        Loading editor
    • Who says you couldn't have an all men's season? Maybe the following year they could have an all women's season to leave the sexism complainers at bay. There have been some really good players forced out of the game too early for things beyond their control. Medical Evacuations have had a direct impact on the outcome of the game leaving fans wondering what if. I think there are some great players that deserve another chance like Terry Deitz and Caleb Reynolds just to name a couple of my favorites.  

        Loading editor
    • Jendav wrote:
      Who says you couldn't have an all men's season? Maybe the following year they could have an all women's season to leave the sexism complainers at bay. There have been some really good players forced out of the game too early for things beyond their control. Medical Evacuations have had a direct impact on the outcome of the game leaving fans wondering what if. I think there are some great players that deserve another chance like Terry Deitz and Caleb Reynolds just to name a couple of my favorites.  

      Oh I absolutely agree many of them deserve another shot, I just don't think doing a single-gender season would be any fun. I like to see both women and men when I watch.

        Loading editor
    • I think a rivals season would be really interesting, people who were notoriously rivals could play against each other. It would be like Courtney Yates (blue team) vs. Jean Robert (Red Team), etc etc. Than later when they merge, it would be interesting to see. Like Dreamz (blue team) and Yao Man (Red Team) and Spencer (Blue team) vs. Kass (Red Team), not necessarily these players they are just examples of how it would be orchestrated. 


      Any ideas for rival pairings? It would be interesting to draft a fantasy cast nonetheless. 

        Loading editor
    • USA vs Canada vs Mexico

        Loading editor
    • Canadians and Mexicans need to be dual citizens to be able to participate. Still it would be an awesome idea.

        Loading editor
    • I would love a "battle of the generations season", like this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DlupUGm9P0Q

        Loading editor
    • I say give military people a chance to do a season where each branch is represented by a tribe you can either have them as secret tribes or let it be known that each member is from a certain branch of the service that way the guys that serve this country so well would have a chance to go through and make a million bucks

        Loading editor
    • Reminder: Don't spoil the unrevealed Game Changers contestants as part of this thread.

        Loading editor
    • If you did a military season there would already be a rivalry between the branches and they would be adapted to the harsh environment already, you could cover many age groups and it woukd be one hell of conflict from the get go

        Loading editor
    • I can definitely see an espionage theme for an Army vs. Navy season. (Adding the Air Force/Coast Guard/etc. would bring the theme too far.)

      Maybe bring back the observer twist as a "spy"...?

        Loading editor
    • I know this was a very controversial twist in Pearl Islands, but this might work better than the original version...


      Outcasts 2.0:

      In an season with 18 castaways, the tribe merges at 12. The "Outcasts" return and the merged tribe of 12 is separated into two teams of 6 with the outcasts being a 3rd team. Instead of two of the outcasts returning into the game, the outcasts can instead get revenge on up to six of the castaways who made merge by cursing them with a vote that will count against them at every Tribal Council they're vulnerable. If the Outcasts come in first place at the challenge, they curse six players (three from each team); if they come in second place, they curse only three people from the team that came in last place; if the outcasts come in last place, they cannot curse anybody.

        Loading editor
    • Right wing vs Left wing battle of the political views

        Loading editor
    • Start with two tribes. Then, at eighteen, two becomes three like in Cambodia and MvGX. However, instead of one auxiliary tribe, all THREE tribes are auxiliary. EVERYONE starts from scratch.

      Also, Survivor: Civil War - East Coast vs. West Coast vs. No Coast. I could see this being North vs. South but I feel like it would be too cheesy. No Coast could include traveling musicians, farmers, etc..

        Loading editor
    • Surferdude1219 wrote: Start with two tribes. Then, at eighteen, two becomes three like in Cambodia and MvGX. However, instead of one auxiliary tribe, all THREE tribes are auxiliary. EVERYONE starts from scratch.

      That's a good idea, but I don't know if the producers could find FIVE beaches for all the tribes.

        Loading editor
    • survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

        Loading editor
    • Pierzina wrote:
      survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

      Please no @quitters. Even if you argue that Naonka would be great to bring back, the producers would never do it. Generally quitters are just terrible. But other than that I like this idea, the only problem being getting enough of these people to agree to it.

        Loading editor
    • Oh, and there's not really enough women who fit in those categories to fill a good cast. It would have to be a 16 person season and probably wouldn't be any good because the cast isn't great.

        Loading editor
    • Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

      Please no @quitters. Even if you argue that Naonka would be great to bring back, the producers would never do it. Generally quitters are just terrible. But other than that I like this idea, the only problem being getting enough of these people to agree to it.

      plenty would say yes and some quitters only quit because of specific circumstances like jenna morasca and terry deitz and they should be allowed to have another chance

        Loading editor
    • Pierzina wrote:
      Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

      Please no @quitters. Even if you argue that Naonka would be great to bring back, the producers would never do it. Generally quitters are just terrible. But other than that I like this idea, the only problem being getting enough of these people to agree to it.
      plenty would say yes and some quitters only quit because of specific circumstances like jenna morasca and terry deitz and they should be allowed to have another chance

      Well Deitz is actually considered an evacuation. And there's still not enough females to fill a good cast, even if all of them did say yes.

        Loading editor
    • Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

      Please no @quitters. Even if you argue that Naonka would be great to bring back, the producers would never do it. Generally quitters are just terrible. But other than that I like this idea, the only problem being getting enough of these people to agree to it.
      plenty would say yes and some quitters only quit because of specific circumstances like jenna morasca and terry deitz and they should be allowed to have another chance
      Well Deitz is actually considered an evacuation. And there's still not enough females to fill a good cast, even if all of them did say yes.

      which is why we get some quitters

        Loading editor
    • Pierzina wrote:
      Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      Surferdude1219 wrote:
      Pierzina wrote:
      survivor: redemption

      everyone who was rock'd out/not "properly" voted out like medevac and idol'd out, maybe even some quitters like jenna morasca/terry deitz

      Please no @quitters. Even if you argue that Naonka would be great to bring back, the producers would never do it. Generally quitters are just terrible. But other than that I like this idea, the only problem being getting enough of these people to agree to it.
      plenty would say yes and some quitters only quit because of specific circumstances like jenna morasca and terry deitz and they should be allowed to have another chance
      Well Deitz is actually considered an evacuation. And there's still not enough females to fill a good cast, even if all of them did say yes.
      which is why we get some quitters

      it's still not enough 

        Loading editor
    • Why not take people from different countries and possibly speak different languages. To be honest it's pretty boring watching so many people play over and over.

      I will represent Canada lol

        Loading editor
    • Why not do Survivor: Forgottens vs. Favorites

        Loading editor
    • What about a crazy twist like Jeff probst going on the jury to vote the sole survivor?

        Loading editor
    • Season 36's title has been spoiled. This should be obvious by now, but don't post the title/theme of season 36 before its official reveal.

        Loading editor
    • One World 2.0:

      This season is similar to the first One World with 18 castaways, but with a twist; the cast will be one entire tribe throughout the entire 39 Days, no tribe swaps, switches, or merge. To determine who wins and who goes to Tribal Council for the first half, they will be divided by teams and the team that wins is immune while the team that loses must attend Tribal, meaning somebody could be on the team that always wins and somebody could be on a team that loses multiple times. The challenges become individual when there is 10 castaways remaining.

        Loading editor
    • I think a great idea would be an entire season of castaways whom are all sons/daughters of previous great players...Terry's son Danny, any of Cirie's kids, Laura M's son, the eldest of the Culpepper's brood, and so on...!! Maybe they need to wait another 5 years to allow more of them to grow and they should have a good enough cast ! there's a chance in 5 years one of the Mariano girls could be old enough !

      it would be called Survivor : Offspring of past legends/greats/ghosts

      whatdya think ??? :D

        Loading editor
    • A location based twist, I really want to see a season in the north, Greenland and Iceland are perfect places

        Loading editor
    • Survivor Vets Vs Big Brother Vets Vs Survivor Rookies

        Loading editor
    • "Survivor: Forged Connections" or something like that, two tribes of nine or ten, everyone on one tribe randomly assigned a partner on the other, if your partner is voted out, you automatically receive a vote against you at your next tribal council.

      "Survivor: Nemesis" or something like that, basically the opposite where you're randomly (and secretly) assigned a target, if they are voted out, you receive a choice of five boxes, one has an immunity necklace for your next tribal, one has a HII clue, one has a reward steal advantage, two have nothing. In play until HIIs can no longer be played.

        Loading editor
    • I'm waiting for the day that Survivor will give Pre-Merge boots or anyone screwed by twists/rocks a chance to play again.

      I personally think giving a season full of Pre-Merge Boots would be a nice change up, and plus it gives much more motivation to root for people, who've been booted pre-merge, to go farther into the game.

      Probably the only returnee season I'd enjoy.

        Loading editor
    • They should do another Phillipines style, 3 tribes with Terry, & 2 other people...if CBS does go ahead with this, they will probably cast someone like Neal & Joe (BvBvB2) instead.....

        Loading editor
    • Greenlabrador wrote:
      I think a great idea would be an entire season of castaways whom are all sons/daughters of previous great players...Terry's son Danny, any of Cirie's kids, Laura M's son, the eldest of the Culpepper's brood, and so on...!! Maybe they need to wait another 5 years to allow more of them to grow and they should have a good enough cast ! there's a chance in 5 years one of the Mariano girls could be old enough !

      it would be called Survivor : Offspring of past legends/greats/ghosts


      whatdya think ??? :D


      good idea


        Loading editor
    • Tribes don't switch and don't merge until there is one remaining player from the opposing tribe. So if there's two tribes of 10, the earliest merge could be at the Final 11 (10 from one tribe, 1 from other tribe) Kind of like Palau, but an on-purpose conquering. The goal would be to conquer the other tribe.

      Also, Survivor:Rivals

      10 returnees come in on a helicopter and await their other castaways. But then their Rivals come out from behind the bushes and surprise them <enter complaining confessionals and "Oh we're gonna have this season!">

      But also there could be people like Shane vs. Courtney , Sierra R. vs. Tyson, Shambo vs. Laura, Alicia vs. Christina, The entire cast of Philippines vs Abi, Woo vs. Abi, Marisa vs. Brad, Kass vs. Trish, Baylor vs. John Rocker, Rodney vs. Mike, and a lot more!

        Loading editor
    • An Outcast
        Loading editor
Like this post
Unlike
See who liked this