|Birth Date||May 6, 1991|
|Tribe(s)|| ██ Ometepe|
|Placement||2nd Runner-Up (3/18)|
|Alliance(s)||Stealth R Us|
Natalie Tenerelli is a contestant from Survivor: Redemption Island.
Name (Age): Natalie Tenerelli (19)
Tribe: Ometepe, Murlonio
Current Residence: Acton, Calif.
Occupation: Professional Dancer
Personal Claim to Fame: Being the youngest female to play the game.
Inspiration in Life: Lady Gaga. Haha, just kidding. My parents have worked extremely hard to give me a good life. They have made it possible for me to follow my dreams and never give up in life. I would hope that in the future I could be half as good of a parent myself.
Hobbies: Dancing, spending time with friends and family, and trying to cook...sometimes this ends badly.
Pet Peeves: When people chomp their food.
3 Words to Describe You: Determined, spontaneous and positive.
SURVIVOR Contestant You Are Most Like: Natalie White from Samoa.
Reason for being on SURVIVOR: To have an experience of a lifetime and prove to myself that I can do anything that I put my mind to.
Why you think you'll "survive" SURVIVOR: I have never quit anything that I have ever done and hopefully my ability to form good relationships with people will help me to "survive" 39 days in this game!
Reason why you think you will be the sole SURVIVOR: I have the charm to win people over and a good intuition about people and their intentions. People may suspect me to be young and naive, but they will be fooled!
Survivor: Redemption IslandEdit
Natalie was a member of the Ometepe tribe and was a member of the successful Stealth R Us alliance consisting of herself, Ashley Underwood, Andrea Boehlke, Matt Elrod, Grant Mattos, and returning player Rob Mariano (Phillip Sheppard became a member of this alliance later on in the game). The alliance dominated the pre-merge stage of the game, only losing their ally Matt due to his relationship with Andrea, and his act of shaking the hands of Zapatera members after their victory in the second Immunity Challenge. Being the youngest member, Natalie was the most subjective to her emotions and had a few moments where she broke down. Over time, the bond being Natalie and Rob began to grow into the point where it became a brother-sister type relationship, which was very reminiscent of the relationship he had with Amber Brkich in Survivor: All-Stars. Natalie also grew closer to her ally Ashley, but despite this, still showed more loyalty to Rob in the end. Natalie made a very tough decision for herself at the Final 4, deciding to betray Ashley and vote her out with the majority. Natalie became the youngest female and castaway to reach the Final 3 stage of the game. At the Final Tribal Council, Natalie received a mixed reception from jury members as many felt she was a coattail rider who followed Rob to the end, although Julie Wolfe and Steve Wright did praise her for being able to have an amazing amount of willpower for her age. Ashley lambasted Natalie for her betrayal, going as far as to call her relationship with Rob "borderline creepy". Natalie received no votes to win Survivor and finished in 3rd.
|Natalie's Voting History|
| Voted Against|
|3||Ometepe Tribe Immune|
|5||Ometepe Tribe Immune|
|6||Ometepe Tribe Immune|
|7||Ometepe Tribe Immune|
| Jury Votes|
|Second Runner-Up, Day 39|
- Natalie became the guest of Survivor Live After Show hosted by Parvati Shallow
- Natalie is the youngest Survivor finalist, reaching the final of Redemption Island at the age of 19.
- Natalie is the youngest female player at the time of filming, being 19 during Survivor: Redemption Island. However, she is not the youngest overall.
- When Jeff was explaining what the reward was in one challenge, Jeff stressed that there would be alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages in the reward, clearly referring to Natalie, who was underage at the time.
- However, the drinking age in Nicaragua is 18, so she was technically able to drink.
- As a member of Stealth R Us, Natalie was nicknamed "Sunshine" by Phillip Sheppard.
- Natalie, Ashley and Andrea were collectively called as "The Three Degrees".
- In the YouTube video "The Jury Speaks: Grant", Grant Mattos stated that he was proud of Natalie since she was able to be on Survivor at such a young age and that he wouldn't have been able to do it if he were 19.
- Natalie is the youngest woman to win individual immunity and the youngest person to win individual immunity to keep it for himself/herself.
- She and Albert Destrade are the only people to receive only one vote against them during the game but receive no jury votes.
|Survivor: Redemption Island Contestants|
Andrea Boehlke · Ashley Underwood · David Murphy · Francesca Hogi · Grant Mattos · Julie Wolfe · Krista Klumpp · Kristina Kell · Matthew Elrod · Mike Chiesl · Natalie Tenerelli · Phillip Sheppard · Ralph Kiser · Rob Mariano · Russell Hantz · Sarita White · Stephanie Valencia · Steve Wright