|Recurring Survivor Challenge|
|Description:||A physically brutal Survivor-style basketball game|
Heroes vs. Villains
Basket Brawl is a recurring challenge that originated in Survivor: Tocantins, and has since reappeared in Heroes vs. Villains, One World, and Cambodia. It is a Survivor version of basketball, albeit more physical.
Held in a partially submerged field of water, three castaways (an equal number of men and women from each tribe) would battle for control over a ball. Once a contestant has acquired the ball, they must throw it into their tribe's respective net, which would score them one point. Every time a point is scored, tribes may swap members in and out of the challenge depending on the stipulation for the upcoming round. The first tribe to score three points would win the challenge.
"The Poison Apple Needs to Go"
| Heroes vs. Villains|
"I'm Not a Good Villain"
| One World|
"A Bunch of Idiots"
"Like Selling Your Soul to the Devil"
Abi-Maria, Ciera, Joe, Spencer, & Tasha
- J.T. Thomas, Stephen Fishbach, and Coach Wade are the only contestants to compete in this challenge twice. J.T. won both times, Stephen won once, while Coach did not win either time.
- Both times the challenge was used on a season with all new players, the winning tribe had all of its season's finalists.