SeasonsGhost IslandHeroes vs. Healers vs. HustlersGame ChangersMillennials vs. Gen XKaôh RōngCambodiaMore...Worlds ApartSan Juan del SurCagayanBlood vs. WaterCaramoanPhilippinesOne WorldSouth PacificRedemption IslandNicaraguaHeroes vs. VillainsSamoaTocantinsGabonMicronesiaChinaFijiCook IslandsPanamaGuatemalaPalauVanuatuAll-StarsPearl IslandsThe AmazonThailandMarquesasAfricaThe Australian OutbackBorneoContestantsGhost IslandAngela PerkinsBradley KleihegeBrendan ShapiroChelsea TownsendChris NobleDesiree AfuyeDomenick AbbateHeroes vs. Healers vs. HustlersAli ElliottAshley NolanBen DriebergenChrissy HofbeckCole MeddersDesi WilliamsDevon PintoGame ChangersOzzy LusthTroyzan RobertsonSandra Diaz-TwineJ.T. ThomasCirie FieldsAndrea BoehlkeJeff VarnerMillennials vs. Gen XMari TakahashiKen McNickleHannah ShapiroJessica LewisBret LaBelleDavid WrightMichaela BradshawKaôh RōngKyle JasonDarnell HamiltonJennifer LanzettiAlecia HoldenAubry BraccoJoe del CampoPeter BaggenstosSole SurvivorsKim SpradlinParvati ShallowRob MarianoRichard HatchSophie ClarkeAmber BrkichJenna MorascaFull ListAbout SurvivorVersionsUnited StatesSwedenAustraliaBrazilColombiaDenmarkFranceNetherlandsNew ZealandPhilippinesSlovakiaSpainSouth AfricaUnited KingdomEpisodesTribesChallengesTwistsGameplayPersonnelMediaSister WikisSurvivor Fanon WikiThe Amazing Race WikiBig Brother Wiki
Survivor Wiki
652 Posts
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
All Contributors
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
+5

Week 2 Discussion Thread

  1. Tai's brain is still a fragile piece of china. He seems to be a genuine person, but too genuine for the game of Survivor.
  2. It's hilarious how JT casually left his entire tribe at sea while he digs for an idol clue back at camp.
  3. Sandra and goats. 'Nuff said.
  4. Brad (I still have a low opinion of him, 50% halfway out of there) is most improved. He's not the arrogant windpipe that he was back in BvW.
  5. If you've watched the MvGx live show, you know Caleb, like Ciera and Tony, was initially introduced there as a returnee. This week, Caleb's gone, and if this trend continues, the entire fanbase will erupt. 
  6. That make-a-wish kid must've been excited to see his challenge and have the possibility of breaking someone's leg again. 
  7. Bellatrix Hali was no game changer by any stretch of the imagination back in WA. Her shining moment was on this season, at that Tribal Council. She mind-effed the tribe into voting Caleb off good.
2 20
  • Upvote
  • Reply
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
Avatar
+5
1
Jacob Number1 wrote:
I've seen a lot of people bashing Sandra for wanting to kill the goat.  To those people: I'm sorry, but if you were going to be on an island for the next 39 days and only had rice and the occasional fish/chicken to eat, you would at least consider, for a brief second, killing the goat (never mind the fact that there's no way in hell production would've let them xD), so stop being self-righteous moralizers. I probably wouldn't have wanted to eat the goat, but, knowing myself, under those circumstances I would've at least thought about it for a few seconds. Sandra was just being blunt about what the rest of the tribe was feeling and not saying, sorry if y'all can't handle the realness. Besides, they already kill chickens to eat, what's so different about the goats? I, for one, am LIVING for OTTN Sandra <3

Actually, they WOULD have let them. The reason the survivors decided against eating the goat was because it was a momma and a baby.  

1
Cosmicbimbo wrote:
Jacob Number1 wrote:
I've seen a lot of people bashing Sandra for wanting to kill the goat.  To those people: I'm sorry, but if you were going to be on an island for the next 39 days and only had rice and the occasional fish/chicken to eat, you would at least consider, for a brief second, killing the goat (never mind the fact that there's no way in hell production would've let them xD), so stop being self-righteous moralizers. I probably wouldn't have wanted to eat the goat, but, knowing myself, under those circumstances I would've at least thought about it for a few seconds. Sandra was just being blunt about what the rest of the tribe was feeling and not saying, sorry if y'all can't handle the realness. Besides, they already kill chickens to eat, what's so different about the goats? I, for one, am LIVING for OTTN Sandra <3
Actually, they WOULD have let them. The reason the survivors decided against eating the goat was because it was a momma and a baby.  

No, I highly doubt they would have. In The Australian Outback, when they killed the pig, Survivor received HUGE backlash and since then they have made it clear that they aren't allowing people to kill wild animals anymore.

1
Tozza6 wrote:
Cosmicbimbo wrote:
Jacob Number1 wrote:
I've seen a lot of people bashing Sandra for wanting to kill the goat.  To those people: I'm sorry, but if you were going to be on an island for the next 39 days and only had rice and the occasional fish/chicken to eat, you would at least consider, for a brief second, killing the goat (never mind the fact that there's no way in hell production would've let them xD), so stop being self-righteous moralizers. I probably wouldn't have wanted to eat the goat, but, knowing myself, under those circumstances I would've at least thought about it for a few seconds. Sandra was just being blunt about what the rest of the tribe was feeling and not saying, sorry if y'all can't handle the realness. Besides, they already kill chickens to eat, what's so different about the goats? I, for one, am LIVING for OTTN Sandra <3
Actually, they WOULD have let them. The reason the survivors decided against eating the goat was because it was a momma and a baby.  
No, I highly doubt they would have. In The Australian Outback, when they killed the pig, Survivor received HUGE backlash and since then they have made it clear that they aren't allowing people to kill wild animals anymore.

In an interview with EW for the is episode, Probst said he wouldn't have stopped them.

0

Ivanornels wrote: Because they are Game Changers. Which is far from a perfect answer judging by this cast, but that's all we can tell you. Survivor has a casting team that determines which kind of players are to be brought back, and we've had winners in previous seasons as well. All Stars, Heroes vs Villains, and Blood vs Water. Interestingly you neglected to ask about JT who also won Tocantins.

I had forgotten JT won Tocantins, tbh. Still, I believe there are Game Changers whoare not winners that the Casting Team have not picked.

1

I'm interested to get confirmation from Dave if he was asked or not. Because I feel he probably turned them down which is why Zeke got on this season. Michaela, simply because of how much focus she had for a premerge player, made a lot of sense for the first choice, with all due respect to Hannah and Jessica.

So far the season is very good. And the episode with the goats, however ugly, reminded me of classic seasons. We don't get such moments anymore on the show, you know, stuff that have nothing to do with strategy, but with the aspect of survival.

I also loved the little moment with Brad Culpepper the designer. It reminded me of Gary Hogeboom, another football player, who posed as a landscape architect.

Am I the only one who finds it somewhat funny that Jeff Varner wears a tie to confessionals? It's funny when people like to look "official" on Survivor, like Bob and his buff-bowtie.

0

I hope this season isn't All-Stars 2.0 where all the interesting/memorable castaways get picked off before the merge with the merge being full of nobodies.

TubbzyWubbzy wrote: I hope this season isn't All-Stars 2.0 where all the interesting/memorable castaways get picked off before the merge with the merge being full of nobodies.

Ikr. I am so nervous, I won't say his name but serveral people told me one of my favourite all time players is out soon... I wanted him to win and now I am so scared :(

SouthParkClydeFan wrote:

TubbzyWubbzy wrote: I hope this season isn't All-Stars 2.0 where all the interesting/memorable castaways get picked off before the merge with the merge being full of nobodies.

Ikr. I am so nervous, I won't say his name but serveral people told me one of my favourite all time players is out soon... I wanted him to win and now I am so scared :(

Well, it was him after all. :/

Write a reply...